20 Books of Summer, #18–19: The Other’s Gold and Black Dogs

Today’s entries in my colour-themed summer reading are a novel about a quartet of college friends and the mistakes that mar their lives and a novella about the enduring impact of war set just after the fall of the Berlin Wall.


The Other’s Gold by Elizabeth Ames (2019)

Make new friends but keep the old,

One is silver and the other’s gold.

Do you know that little tune? We would sing it as a round at summer camp. It provides a clever title for this story of four college roommates whose lives are marked by the threat of sexual violence and ambivalent feelings about motherhood. Alice, Ji Sun, Lainey and Margaret first meet as freshmen in 2002 when they’re assigned to the same suite (with a window seat! how envious am I?) at Quincy-Hawthorn College.

They live together for the whole four years – a highly unusual situation – and see each other through crises at college and in the years to come as they find partners and meander into motherhood. Iraq War protests and the Occupy movement form a turbulent background, but the friends’ overriding concerns are more personal. One girl was molested by her brother as a child and has kept secret her act of revenge; one has a crush on a professor until she learns he has sexual harassment charges being filed against him by multiple female students. Infertility later provokes jealousy between the young women, and mental health issues come to the fore.

As in Expectation by Anna Hope, the book starts to be all about babies at a certain point. That’s not a problem if you’re prepared for and interested in this theme, but I love campus novels so much that my engagement waned as the characters left university behind. Also, the characters seemed too artificially manufactured to inject diversity (Ji Sun is a wealthy Korean; adopted Lainey is of mixed Latina heritage, and bisexual; Margaret has Native American blood) and embody certain experiences. And, unfortunately, any #MeToo-themed read encountered in the wake of My Dark Vanessa is going to pale by comparison.

Part One held my interest, but after that I skimmed to the end. Ideally, I would have chosen replacements and not included skims like this and Green Mansions, but it’s not the first summer that I’ve had to count DNFs and skimmed books – my time and attention are always being diverted by paid review work, review copies and library books with imminent deadlines. I’ve read lots of fiction about groups of female friends this summer, partly by accident and partly by design, and will likely do a feature on it in an upcoming month. For now, I’d recommend Lara Feigel’s The Group instead of this.

With thanks to Pushkin Press (ONE imprint) for the free e-copy for review.


Black Dogs by Ian McEwan (1992)

When I read the blurb, I worried I’d read this before and forgotten it: all it mentions is a young couple setting off on honeymoon and having an encounter with evil. Isn’t that the plot of The Comfort of Strangers? I thought. In fact, this only happens to have the vacation detail in common, and has a very different setup and theme overall.

Jeremy lost his parents in a car accident (my least favourite fictional trope – far too convenient a way of setting a character off on their own!) when he was eight years old, and is self-aware enough to realize that he has been seeking for parental figures ever after. He becomes deeply immersed in the story of his wife’s parents, Bernard and June, even embarking on writing a memoir based on what June, from her nursing home bed, tells him of their early life (Part One).

After June’s death, Jeremy takes Bernard to Berlin (Part Two) to soak up the atmosphere just after the Wall comes down, but the elderly man is kicked by a skinhead. The other key thing that happens on this trip is that he refutes June’s account of their honeymoon. At June’s old house in France (Part Three), Jeremy feels her presence and seems to hear the couple’s voices. Only in Part Four do we learn what happened on their 1946 honeymoon trip to France: an encounter with literal black dogs that also has a metaphorical dimension, bringing back the horrors of World War II.

I think the novel is also meant to contrast Communist ideals – Bernard and June were members of the Party in their youth – with how Communism has played out in history. It was shortlisted for the Booker, which made me feel that I must be missing something. A fairly interesting read, most similar in his oeuvre (at least of the 15 I’ve read so far) to The Child in Time. (Secondhand purchase from a now-defunct Newbury charity shop)


Coming up next: The latest book by John Green – it’s due back at the library on the 31st so I’ll aim to review it before then, possibly with a rainbow-covered novel as a bonus read.

16 responses

  1. I was attracted by the structure of The Other’s Gold when it was first published but have yet to read a review from a reader who wholeheartedly recommended it. It sounds a bit like a box-ticking exercise as far as characters are concerned.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Yes, I felt that way about the characters. A shame as you and I share a love for books about groups of friends.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Hahaha you know how I felt about the focus on motherhood in Expectation so I think I’ll be giving The Other’s Gold a miss! Also don’t like box-ticking diversity.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Definitely missable! Despite the promising setup.

      Liked by 1 person

  3. Well I have read Black Dogs back in the day, and all I can remember was that it was partly set in Germany – nothing else at all. However, I don’t think its a McEwan that I’ll rush to re-read.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I think it would have had a lot more impact back then, just a few years after the Wall fell. I keep exploring his backlist even though I tend to like his newer stuff better.


  4. That is a shame about The Other’s Gold! I get annoyed when books get bogged down in babies and it sounds a bit writing-exercise / creative writing course=y.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I wouldn’t be surprised to learn she started writing it as part of a creative writing degree. I hope you’ll enjoy The Group when you get to it.

      Liked by 1 person

  5. Oh, my…I remember that little poem from the days of Autograph Books (and, later, yearbooks). And I thought that description sounded like Comfort of Strangers too, so now I’m curious how different this one would be with all those tenets in common.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. It’s mostly the structure of this McEwan that’s different: in several discrete sections, and voiced by a not-totally-objective narrator.


  6. Sorry to hear neither of these worked for you! Was there something in the first one that made the diversity feel forced? It sounds like a pretty normal group of college students to me, so I’m wondering if the author did a bad job with characterization as well.


    1. I don’t know if it’s different elsewhere, but the private Mid-Atlantic college I attended was very white. It would have been rare to have ONE student out of four with non-white heritage, let alone three. It felt like the diversity details were shoehorned in. And yes, the characterization wasn’t as strong as it needed to be to keep me interested in the ensemble cast.


      1. Thanks for your response! I feel like diversity can be a fraught topic, but I was really interested in your thoughts on how it was done here. It sounds like you felt like the diverse characters were out of place here because they didn’t match your experience with this setting. My undergrad institution was also very white, but my experience TAing in grad school included a much more diverse bunch of students, so that probably shaped my reaction to the character descriptions 🙂


      2. My elementary school and high school were very diverse (I was in the ‘minority’ there!), but once I got to college the picture was different. Where I live in England is also very homogeneous. The fictional institution here was supposed to be in New England, which is very white from my limited experience. It’s an interesting question of whether fiction should depict places as they are, or as they should be in an ideal world.


  7. […] this theme, I have also read: The Other’s Gold by Elizabeth Ames, Catch the Rabbit by Lana Bastašić, The Group by Lara Feigel (and Mary […]


Leave a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: