Out and About in Edinburgh

After going to Wigtown in April, I never expected I’d be back in Scotland this year. This was a fairly last-minute trip we booked so that my husband could attend a short rewilding workshop for PhD students. They all met up in Edinburgh and proceeded by bus into the Cairngorms to see sites of habitat restoration and potential future wildlife releases. I stayed behind at our Airbnb flat and kept up a reduced work load while enjoying the city break.

Day 1, Wednesday the 19th: A travel day. Our journey – two train rides plus a short walk at either end – should have taken just over 7 hours. Instead, it took 14. Recent storms had taken down wires at Durham and left debris on the line, so our original train was terminated at York. We managed to get a connection to Newcastle, queued outside for two hours for rail replacement buses that never came, and finally got a very delayed train through to Edinburgh. Our poor Airbnb hostess’s parents had to wait up for us until 12:40 a.m.


Day 2, Thursday the 20th: After just a few hours of sleep, we were up early so that Chris could leave by 7:15 for his meet-up on the Edinburgh campus. The props and sketches scattered about suggest that the flat owner is a theatre costume and set designer. The view overlooking Holyrood Park and Arthur’s Seat is spectacular – a great place to put in a few hours of proofreading before heading out to town after lunch.


On Clare’s recommendation I started with the Surgeons’ Hall Museums on the Royal College of Surgeons campus. They have several collections covering the history of surgery, dentistry, and pathology specimens. Many of the names and developments were familiar to me from Lindsey Fitzharris’s The Butchering Art. Joseph Lister’s frock coat is on display, and in one corner rare video footage plays of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle (who was initially a practicing physician) explaining how he based Sherlock Holmes on his university mentor, Joseph Bell.

It’s not a place for the squeamish as there are mummified skeletons, details about Burke and Hare’s grave-robbing, surgical tools, and tumors and other anatomical deformities in jars everywhere. I found it all fascinating and spent a good two hours poking around. My favorite bits were the case full of foreign bodies removed from noses, stomachs and intestines and the temporary exhibition, “A Quest for Healing” by Zhang Yanzi, who had a residency at the museums in the summer of 2017. Her pieces included a 2D mountain made of pill packets, a cotton and gauze sculpture bristling with acupuncture needles, a matching hanging sculpture of capillaries, two surgical beds, and various silk screen panels.

The pathology museum, spread across two floors, was a little overwhelming and almost distressingly faceless – so many human beings reduced to the conditions that had defined and perhaps killed them. The most striking specimen for me, then, was one that actually included a face. I think it was a First World War soldier whose nose had been sewn back together, and what was so remarkable was that you could see his ginger whiskers and eyebrows, and his eyes were closed as if he was just taking a nap. (For ever. In a museum case.)

The sculpture outside is From Here Health by Denys Mitchell (1994).

There are only explanatory panels about a select few samples, so it can be hard to spot just what’s wrong with the organs unless you have specialist medical knowledge. I appreciated the few places where notes have been added along the lines of “see your doctor if…” There were four polycystic kidneys on display in various cases, so including mine there were at least six present in the building that day. “More lives would be saved if more people carried kidney donor cards,” one caption read. Amen.

Clare also recommended the university area for its charity shops. I had a good trawl around Nicolson Street and bought one book, but a lot of the shops are geared towards vintage and High Street fashion. I had better luck at the Salvation Army store on Forrest Road (near the National Museum), where I found three books and two classical CDs.

On to the Writers’ Museum, which commemorates Robert Burns, Sir Walter Scott and Robert Louis Stevenson. I was most interested in the Stevenson material, including memorabilia from his later life on Samoa, especially as I’m currently reading a novel about his relationship with the American divorcee Fanny Osbourne. By now I was museum-ed out and headed back to the flat for a leftovers dinner and some reading before an early bedtime.


Day 3, Friday the 21st: Another morning of work followed by an afternoon of wandering on foot between free attractions and charity shops and avoiding the drizzle. I visited the unusual Scottish Parliament building (which cost a cool £414 million) and saw inside the debating chamber. Four books from the Lothian Cat Rescue charity shop; quick jaunts around the Museum of Childhood, the Museum of Edinburgh, Canongate Kirk, the Music Museum, and the Central Library. When it came to it I couldn’t be bothered to pay £14 to go around Holyrood Palace, but I enjoyed a reasonably priced cappuccino and carrot cake at their café. Chris was back in the evening for a dinner of frozen pizza with local beer and cider.


Day 4, Saturday the 22nd: Our one full day in the City together. We weren’t feeling up to the Arthur’s Seat walk, so we did a gentle stroll up the Salisbury Crags and back instead. Then we caught a bus out to the Stockbridge area for more charity shopping (two more books) and a scrumptious brunch at The Pantry. This was a recommendation on chef David Lebovitz’s food blog and it more than lived up to expectations. It’s no wonder we had to wait half an hour for a table. I could have eaten anything on the menu, but in the end I had smoked salmon eggs Benedict followed by a cherry and Nutella brownie.

After a brief browse at Golden Hare Books, we went on along the Water of Leith to the lovely Royal Botanic Garden. It’s free to walk around, but we also paid to tour the Glasshouses, which recreate the flora of 10 different climates. The RBG is also home to the National Memorial for Organ and Tissue Donors, a peaceful circular space set back in the woods and marked out by a few benches and stone monuments. As I have organ donors to thank for the continued life and health of my mother and several other relatives, it was well worth a visit.

Back into town for gelato (I had a delicious poached plum and cinnamon sorbet) at Mary’s Milk Bar, which is on Grassmarket across from the Castle and was another Lebovitz recommendation. A quick circuit of the animal hall at the National Museum before it closed, a stroll along the Royal Mile, and a rest with tea and books back at the flat before going back out for a veggie curry.


Airbnb bedroom reading nook

Day 5, Sunday the 23rd: Return travel day. No major issues, but still enough of a delay to apply for compensation – refunds from LNER and my husband’s work will have made the journey very cheap indeed.

I was sad to leave Edinburgh this time. I loved our Airbnb flat and felt very at home in it. If I had a bicycle to get into town a little faster, I could easily live there. The tourists would probably drive me mad, but Edinburgh is a wonderful place with so much to see and do and such incredible scenery within a short drive.

Thank you to everyone who offered suggestions of what to see and do. I managed to fit in most of what you recommended!


What I read:

The bulk of Unsheltered, Barbara Kingsolver’s bold new novel about distrust and displacement in America then (the 1870s) and now (during the rise of Trump), and Come to Me by Amy Bloom, a wonderful story collection about people who love who they shouldn’t love. More about this one in my upcoming round-up of short stories I’ve read this month. 4-star-rating

A Ladder to the Sky by John Boyne is a delicious piece of literary suspense with a Tom Ripley-like hero you’ll love to hate: Maurice Swift, who wants nothing more than to be a writer but doesn’t have any ideas of his own, so steals them from other people. I loved how we see this character from several outside points of view – first Erich Ackerman, whose Nazi-era history provides the basis for Maurice’s first novel; then Gore Vidal, to whose Italian home Maurice pays a visit with his new mentor; and finally Maurice’s wife Edith, a celebrated author in her own right – before getting Maurice’s own perspective. By this point we know enough about him to understand just how unreliable a narrator he is. My one criticism is that I would have binned the whole subplot about Edith’s sister and brother-in-law. (A nice touch: at one point Maurice buys a reprint copy of Maude Avery’s Like to the Lark, which should ring a bell from The Heart’s Invisible Furies.) 4-star-rating


I also read over half of Jenny Diski’s Stranger on a Train, a memoir about two long train journeys she took across America in the late 1990s that also incorporates memories from a troubled adolescence – she started smoking at 14 and was in and out of mental hospitals at 15 – in which she loved nothing more than to read while riding the Circle line all day long. I’m a quarter of the way through both Nancy Horan’s Under the Wide and Starry Sky, about Stevenson and his wife, and Peter Hill’s Stargazing, a memoir about dropping out of art school to become a Scottish lighthouse keeper in 1973; he started on Pladda, a tiny island off of Arran. And on my Nook I read a good bit of All You Can Ever Know, Nicole Chung’s forthcoming memoir about being raised by adoptive white parents in Oregon and meeting members of her Korean family in her mid-twenties, just as she became a mother herself.

31 responses

  1. What a wonderful travelogue, especially with your personal connections to what you saw. Truly a charmed place.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Nutella and cherry brownies, botancial gardens and that lovely looking Airbnb: you’ve made me want to get on the next train to Edinburgh, although hopefully not such a horribly delayed one as yours. Commiserations with that.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. It didn’t particularly matter as we had no plans for the first evening beyond finding dinner, but it did make for a scant night’s sleep. It was truly the perfect Airbnb, and I enjoyed my third visit to the City just as much as or more than the first two.

      Liked by 1 person

  3. I adore Amy Bloom’s _Come to Me_ and can’t wait to hear what you have to say about it. That collection made me think, maybe I can do this writing thing! And _As the World Spins_, McCann’s best, I think. The Boyne book sounds fun!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I didn’t think all that much of the first novel I read by Bloom (White Houses, earlier this year), but her stories are terrific. Not a dud in the bunch. So neat to hear that this book was part of what started you off as a writer!

      I’ve only read one book by McCann, Thirteen Ways of Looking, but it was so fantastic I intend to read everything else he’s written.


  4. What a lovely trip – thank you for sharing it with us I haven’t been to Edinburgh for years but I remember really liking it.

    How was the Kingsolver? I think Mr Liz and I are going to read it together soon.

    How lovely that there’s an organ donors’ memorial. I recently worked as an official at the Transplant Games and went straight on the register when I got home (I thought I already was, to be fair).

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Good for you for joining the organ donors’ register. I think there has been a movement afoot to make it an opt-out system? (i.e., you are automatically registered as a donor unless you specifically remove yourself from the list). It just seems silly for perfectly functional organs to be burned or buried when they could save or prolong a life.

      Unsheltered is very good. I’m about 90 pages from the end. I will probably rate it 4 stars, with the caveat that its messages (about healthcare, the environment, Trump, etc.) and connections are quite heavyhanded. It will be out in the UK on Oct. 18th.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Yes, that’s correct, but I wasn’t going to wait for that to happen. My husband had a friend who was a recipient of an entire digestive system and I have a lung transplant friend, so I thought I’d done it already and it was important.
        And thanks for the report on the Kingsolver. She can be a bit messagey and we forgive that for her great writing – she’s also apparently narrated the audiobook herself again, which my husband is pleased about. We’re so looking forward to this one.

        Liked by 1 person

  5. Oooh jealous! I visited the Writers’ Museum for the first time last year, whilst developing an RLS obsession, and I loved it! 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

    1. The RLS holdings were definitely the most interesting. I think I’ve only ever read his Treasure Island, as a child, but I have Travels with a Donkey and mean to read that soon (I’ve read two updates/repeats of his journey, Footsteps by Richard Holmes and To Travel Hopefully by Christopher Rush — do you know those?).


      1. Travels with a Donkey is great fun – I read and reviewed recently. But I hadn’t heard of the other two books, so thank you! 🙂

        Liked by 1 person

  6. Glad you had a good trip. I forgot to mention I visited Stockbridge too – so many charity bookshops on one street! I didn’t know about the organ donor memorial so will look out for that next time I visit. I also enjoyed A Ladder to the Sky and am jealous that you have a copy of Unsheltered!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Stockbridge was a really neat area. We could have eaten in any number of the cafes and restaurants. Alas, one of the bigger charity shops there was closed on Saturday afternoon with no explanation. I had the same thing happen with the Poetry Library on the Royal Mile. Locked doors and no sign. But I still saw and did tons in the few days I was there.

      It’s very different from Boyne’s previous novel but almost as good, I thought. He writes in lots of subtly different genres and seems to be successful in all of them.


  7. Great post – I love Edinburgh. Interesting to read that there are others with aN RLS obsession – thought I was the only one! The Writers’ Museum is fascinating and I’ve followed an RLS trail right across the world to Northern California too (where there’s another excellent museum commemorating him and the lady in charge gave me a personal tour).
    Couldn’t get on with the Nancy Horan book so will be interested to see what you think of it.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. It’s fairly slow compared to Loving Frank, but I’m enjoying it well enough. It’s reminding me a bit of The Moon and Sixpence, or maybe that’s just my projection because I know there will be scenes set in the South Pacific as well as France.


  8. The Surgeons’ Hall Museums sound fascinating. And your lunch at The Pantry makes me jealous! MMMM.

    Wonderful post – made me want to move Edinborough to the top of want to visit’ list.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. It was a great trip. I do recommend Edinburgh. I’m not usually a big city person, but it’s small enough that you can see a lot in a few days and getting around feels manageable if you get on the occasional bus.


  9. Sounds like you had a great trip – I do love a visit to Edinburgh. A nice Seamus Heaney find too 😙

    Liked by 1 person

    1. And for 50p! Such a steal. Some of the poems are familiar for me, but lots will be new.


  10. Oh what a lovely trip. Edinburgh is really charming; it’s definitely on my shortlist of Places That Aren’t London that I Might Conceivably Live In Some Day. Pleased you enjoyed Unsheltered, too; I thought it very good.

    Liked by 1 person

  11. Great post! V.jealous of your visits to the medical museums (I have The Butchering Art in my reading stack, I think on your recommendation).

    I’m about to read the new Boyne, looking forward to it. How are you finding the Horan (I was bitterly disappointed after having read the fabulous Loving Frank).

    Liked by 1 person

    1. It’s a pretty slow read compared to Loving Frank, but I’ll persist. Ladder is very different to Boyne’s previous book, but great fun in a sleazy sort of way. I hope you’ll enjoy it too.

      Liked by 1 person

  12. Ah, I love Edinburgh though unfortunately the only one of my family that does. The Surgeons’ Museum is macabre but also fascinating and I think quite a tender reflection of the wide variations of the human condition. I found it strangely consoling and life-affirming. The Airbnb looks excellent. Would be interested to hear your thoughts on the Diski, it’s one I haven’t read yet though being honest I have adored her other non-fiction so am perhaps a little biased and would expect to love it. Sorry to hear about the train delays, though not much they can do about the terrible weather I suppose.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. This is only the second book I’ve read by Diski, after Skating to Antarctica. I’m over halfway through now and I’m enjoying it very much.

      Liked by 1 person

  13. I can’t believe how much goodness you packed into your trip! From the places you went and the pictures you took, I think I would like it there. My mother and sister have both been there, and my husband went to Scotland years ago as a bike tour guide.(Even though he had never been there before.)
    As much as I loved hearing about the museums, I especially love hearing about the food you ate! And the books all sound great, too.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Edinburgh has so much to do but is a lot less overwhelming than London, and has a beautiful mountainous setting. If we’d been able to stay longer (and had our original train arrival time!) we would have tried more restaurants. There were so many great ones to choose from.

      Liked by 1 person

  14. That sounds amazing! I like the combination of chatter about all the different parts of your exploring. But especially the books, of course. And I love that there is a bookshop for cat rescues! Once you had survived the train trip to get there, how was it to get around the city: Buses or walking: is transit easy to manage, or did you end up asking for directions a lot?


    1. I had to go to Lothian Cat Rescue just for the name, but it also ended up having the cheapest books of the trip at 50 pence each. I mostly walked, and thanks to our pull-out map from a library guidebook I never got lost. The only time we needed buses was to go to and from Stockbridge, as that’s quite a ways outside the city center and the other side of it from our accommodation. The only downside to the buses is that they require exact change. I think there are also trams, though we never took one.


  15. […] #4 Whenever I think of Our Souls at Night, I remember John Boyne’s crude Twitter joke about someone asking a bookshop for “Arseholes at Night.” I’ve enjoyed a couple of Boyne’s novels, including A Ladder to the Sky, a Ripley-esque work of suspense (review here). […]


  16. […] a literary chameleon. He’s been John Irving (The Heart’s Invisible Furies), Patricia Highsmith (A Ladder to the Sky) and David Mitchell (A Traveller at the Gates of Wisdom). Now, with this Internet-age […]


Leave a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: