Classic of the Month: Under the Net (#IMReadalong)

I plan to dip in and out of Liz Dexter’s two-year Iris Murdoch readalong project to increase my familiarity with Murdoch and get through some of the paperbacks I happen to own. Even though I don’t own it, I decided to join in with Under the Net (1954) to see how her fiction career began. My university library copy is a rebound 1960s Penguin paperback, so – alas! – has a generic cover. See Liz’s introductory post for the different cover images and to get a peek at some of the recurring Murdochian themes that make their first appearance here.

Under the Net is narrated by Jake Donoghue, a translator who arrives back in London after a trip to France to find that he’s being kicked out of the flat where he’s been living for free with his friend Finn. In his desultory search for where to go next he takes readers along to Mrs Tinckham’s cat-filled shop, his Jewish philosopher friend Dave’s place, and the theatre where a former girlfriend, Anna Quentin, is in charge of props. (One of my favorite scenes has him accidentally locked into the theatre overnight; he has to sleep among the costumes.)

Anna’s sister Sadie, an actress, offers Jake a role as her bodyguard; she has a stalker of sorts, fireworks manufacturer and film studio owner Hugo Belfounder – whom, it turns out, Jake already knows. Together they were guinea pigs for an experiment on the common cold, and Jake secretly worked up Hugo’s conversations into a poorly received book called The Silencer. “Hugo was my destiny,” Jake muses; even though he’s embarrassed to see Hugo again, he gets drawn back into a connection with him.

One of the central themes of the novel, playing out with various characters, is the difficulty of seeing people clearly rather than resting with the image of them you’ve built up in your mind. I enjoyed Jake’s contrasting of physical and intellectual work, and his (sometimes contradictory) reflections on solitude and introversion:

I sometimes feel that Finn has very little inner life. I mean no disrespect to him in saying this; some have and some haven’t. I connect this too with his truthfulness. Subtle people, like myself, can see too much ever to give a straight answer.

I hate solitude, but I am afraid of intimacy. The substance of my life is a private conversation with myself which to turn into a dialogue would be equivalent to self-destruction. The company which I need is the company which a pub or a café will provide.

If like myself you are a connoisseur of solitude, I recommend to you the experience of being alone in Paris on the fourteenth of July.

Many readers probably expect Murdoch’s books to be dense and difficult, bogged down with philosophical ideas. But what I most noticed about this first novel is how humorous it is: it’s even madcap in places, with some coming and going via windows and Mister Mars, the film star dog, playing dead to get Jake out of a sticky situation. Over at Liz’s blog we’ve been discussing whether Murdoch is a typical ‘woman writer’; if her books had been published anonymously or under her initials, would it have been assumed that she was a man? I think so, given her success in creating a male narrator and her focus on the world of work and less traditional domestic arrangements.

This is my sixth Murdoch book. I didn’t enjoy Under the Net as much as the Booker Prize-winning The Sea, The Sea or The Bell (), but liked it more than The Black Prince and An Unofficial Rose () [I’ve also read one of her philosophy books, The Fire and the Sun (; I could make neither head nor tail of it)], so it falls in the middle for me so far at a solid . I’m looking forward to participating with several more of the readalong books next year, starting with A Severed Head in March.

Another favorite line, spoken by Hugo: “One must just blunder on. Truth lies in blundering on.”


Have you read anything by Iris Murdoch? Do you enjoy her work?

Join us for one or more of the readalong books!

13 responses

  1. A lovely review, thank you. I’m so glad people have been finding and talking about the humour – and madcap/farcical scenes certainly occur in many of the books.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. I read this years ago and am hoping that there is still a copy lurking somewhere on my shelves. When I reach the appropriate year in my survey of literature written in my life time I intend to read Murdoch whenever she published.

    Liked by 2 people

    1. Do pop into Liz’s blog for some Murdoch reading or (especially) re-reading.

      Liked by 1 person

  3. I thought this was one of the Murdochs I’ve read, and went into it thinking I would be rereading, but nothing seemed familiar and, when I checked my log, I realised I’d confused it with An Unofficial Rose (because there are three words in the title? probably). Like you, I was struck by the humour in it. I’ve read a few of her others but none of her non-fiction, though I suspect I’d feel as lost in it as you were!

    Liked by 2 people

    1. I read the Sartre book for my Century of Reading and had the very odd experience of understanding each sentence as I read it but being lost afterwards!

      Liked by 2 people

      1. I’m okay with theology because I have a lot of background, but I really struggle with philosophy. I audited one Introduction to Philosophy course in college and it was doable only because I had a great professor and a very basic textbook.

        Liked by 1 person

    2. I know I read Unofficial Rose, perhaps in 2009, but I have zero memory of what happens in it. That was in the days before I kept notes or wrote even mini-reviews of my reading, so those books are effectively lost to me.

      Liked by 1 person

  4. I’ve read all of her fiction and some of her philosophy. I’m now embarking on re-reading her fiction from beginning to end once again. The Red and the Green is next.

    Liked by 2 people

    1. Ah, you’d be well ahead of schedule on Liz’s readalong — that one doesn’t come until July 2018! Drop in with some thoughts about your recent re-reading as you go. Do you have a favorite Murdoch or two?

      Liked by 1 person

  5. […] Beck has reviewed the book on her blog. She’s read four other Murdochs and placed it squarely in the middle in terms of favourites, […]


  6. […] in Under the Net, we have a male narrator; here it’s Martin Lynch-Gibbon, 41, a wine merchant’s son who’s […]


Leave a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: